Compare Tata Punch EV vs MG Comet EV vs MG Astor

Punch EV vs Comet EV vs Astor Features

• Safety

  NCAP Rating (Best - 5 Star)	5 Star (Bharat NCAP)	Not Tested	Not Tested
  Airbags	6 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger, 2 Curtain, Driver Side, Front Passenger Side)	2 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger)	2 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger)
  Seat Belt Warning
  Child Lock
  Anchor Points for Child Seat
  Overspeed Warning	1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph	1 beep over 80kmph	1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph
  Speed Sensing Door Lock
  Anti theft Engine immobilizer
  Middle rear three-point seatbelt
  Flashing Emergency Brake Light
  Central Locking	With Key	Keyless	Keyless
  Puncture Repair Kit

• Sensors, Warnings, & Indicators

  Type of Instrument Cluster / Dashboard Display	Digital	Digital	Digital
  Mileage or Average Fuel Consumption
  Real Time Mileage
  Average Speed
  Distance to Empty
  Trip Meter	Electronic 2 Trips	-	Electronic 2 Trips
  Low Fuel Warning
  Door Not Closed Warning
  Adjustable Cluster Brightness
  Active Gear Display
  Tyre Pressure Monitoring (TPMS)
  Parking Sensors	Rear	Rear	Rear
  Clock	Digital	Digital	Digital
  Headlights On Reminder
  Tachometer

• Telematics

  Find My Car
  Vehicle Status on App
  Remote Car Lock/Unlock Via app
  Remote AC Control Via app
  Remote Car Light Flashing & Honking Via app
  Emergency Call
  Geo-Fence

• Music and Infotainment

  Integrated Music System
  Infotainment Display
  Voice Command Support
  Android / Apple Connectivity	Android Auto (No), Apple Car Play (No)	Android Auto (No), Apple Car Play (No)	Android Auto (Wired), Apple Car Play (Wired)
  Steering Mounted Controls
  GPS & Navigation
  Speakers
  FM Radio
  Bluetooth Connectivity
  USB / Pen-Drive Support
  Aux Support
  iPod Compatibility
  MP3 Playback

• Comfort & Convenience

  Steering Adjustment
  Air Conditioner	Yes (Automatic Climate Control)	Yes (Manual)	Yes (Automatic Climate Control)
  Air Purifier
  Heater
  Front AC	Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control	Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control	Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control
  Rear AC	-	-	Blower, Vents Behind Front Armrest
  Vanity Mirrors on Sun Visors
  Anti-glare Rear View Mirrors
  12V Power Outlets
  Boot Access from the Last Row Seats
  Head Rest for Middle Rear Seat

• Braking & Traction

  Brake Type - Front	Disc	Disc	Disc
  Break Type - Rear	Drum	Drum	Disc
  ABS - Anti Lock Braking System
  EBD - Electronic Brake-force Distribution
  Brake Assist in Emergency (BA)
  Electronic Stability Program (ESP)
  Traction Control
  Hill Hold Assist
  Hill Descent Control

• Seats

  Seat Upholstery	Fabric	Fabric	Fabric
  Adjustment Options - Driver Seat	8 way manually adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, headrest: up / down, seat height: up / down)	4 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back)	8 way manually adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, headrest: up / down, seat height: up / down)
  Adjustment Options - Front Passanger Seat	6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)	4 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back)	6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)
  Adjustment Options - Rear Row Seat	2 way manually adjustable (headrest: up / down)	-	2 way manually adjustable (headrest up / down)
  Driver Armrest
  Armrest for Rear Seat
  Headrests	Front & Rear	Front & Rear	Front & Rear
  Rear Passenger Seats Type	Bench	Bench	Bench
  Folding Rear Seat	Full	Full	Full
  Split Rear Seat

• Doors, Windows Mirrors & Wipers

  Power Windows	Front Only	Front Only	Front & Rear
  WIndow Control: One Touch - Up
  Window Control: One Touch -Down
  Rear Wiper
  Rear Glass Defogger
  Exterior Door Handles	Black	Chrome	Chrome
  Interior Door Handles	Black	Chrome	Chrome
  Outside Rear View Mirrors (ORVMs)	Black	Body Coloured	Body Coloured
  Adjustable ORVM	Internally Adjustable	Electrically Adjustable	Electrically Adjustable
  Turn Indicators on ORVM
  Boot / Dikki Opener	Electric Tailgate Release	Remote Operated	Electric Tailgate Release

• Head & Tail Lights

  Headlights	LED	Halogen	LED
  Headlight Height Adjuster
  Follow me home head Lights
  Cornering Headlights
  Daytime Running Lights	Not Sure	Halogen	LED
  Fog Lamps	-	LED	Halogen,Halogen
  Tail Light	Halogen	Halogen	LED

• Interiors, Lights & Storage inside Cabin

  Interiors	Dual Tone	Single Tone	Dual Tone
  Leather-wrapped Steering
  Interior Colour(s)	Black / White	Starlight Black	Iconic Ivory / Black
  Lights inside Cabin	Front	Front	Front and Rear
  Cup Holders	Front Only	Front Only	Front & Rear
  Cooled Glove Box
  Light inside Glove Box
  Storage in Driver Armrest
  Pockets inside Door	Front & Rear	Front	Front & Rear
  Pockets in Front Seat-back
  Reading Lamp for Rear Passengers

• Exterior

  Roof Mounted Antenna
  Chrome Finish Exhaust pipe
  Body Coloured Bumpers
  Body Kit
  Rub - Strips

• Manufacturer Warranty

  Warranty (Years)
  Warranty (Max Kilometres)	125000	Not Applicable	Unlimited
  Battery Warranty (Years)	8	8	Not Applicable
  Battery Warranty (Max Kilometres)	160000	120000	Not Applicable

Punch EV vs Comet EV vs Astor Specifications

• Engine & Performance

  Fuel Type	Electric	Electric	Petrol
  Transmission	Automatic - 1 Gears	Automatic - 1 Gears, Sport Mode	Manual - 5 Gears
  Time for 0-100 kmph Acceleration	13.5	19.97	-
  Driving Range (km)	315	230	-
  Engine	-	Not Applicable Cylinders Not Applicable, Not Applicable Valves/Cylinder, Not Applicable	1498 cc, 4 Cylinders Inline, 4 Valves/Cylinder, DOHC
  Engine Type	-	-	VTi-TECH 1.5
  Peak Power (bhp@rpm)	-	-	108 bhp @ 6000 rpm
  Peak Torque (Nm@rpm)	-	-	144 Nm @ 4400 rpm
  Electric Motor	1 Permanent magnet synchronous Placed At Front Axle	1 Permanent magnet synchronous Placed At Rear Axle	-
  Peak Motor Performance	80 bhp, 114 Nm	41 bhp, 110 Nm	-
  Battery	25 kWh, Lithium Ion,Battery Placed Under Floor Pan	17.3 kWh, Lithium Ion,Battery Placed Under Front Seats	-
  Drivetrain	FWD	RWD	FWD
  Others	Regenerative Braking, Pure Electric Driving Mode	Regenerative Braking	-
  Emission Standard	Not Applicable	Not Applicable	BS6 Phase 2

• Steering, Tyres, & Suspnsions

  Steering Type	Power assisted (Electric)	Power assisted (Electric)	Power assisted (Electric)
  Minimum Turning Radius	5	4.2	5.6
  Suspension - Front	Independent, Lower Wishbone, McPherson Strut with Coil Spring	McPherson Strut	MacPherson Strut
  Suspension - Rear	Semi-independent Twist Beam With Coil Spring And Shock Absorber	Multi-Link Coil Suspension	Torsion Beam
  Wheels Type	Steel Rims	Steel Rims	Steel Rims
  Tyres Size - Front	185 / 70 R15	145 / 70 R12	215 / 55 R17
  Tyres Size - Rear	185 / 70 R15	145 / 70 R12	215 / 55 R17
  Spare Wheel	Steel	No	Steel

• Size, Weight, & Dimensions

  Bootspace / Dicky Capacity (L)	366	-	488
  Fuel Tank Capacity (L)	-	-	48
  Passenger Capacity	5	4	5
  Length (mm)	3857	2974	4323
  Width (mm)	1742	1505	1809
  Height (mm)	1633	1640	1650
  Wheelbase (mm)	2445	2010	2585
  Ground Clearance (mm)	190	-	-
  Curb Weight (kgs)	-	-	1303
  No of Seating Rows	2	2	2
  No of Doors	5	3	5

Punch EV vs Comet EV vs Astor Expert Opinion

Punch EV vs Comet EV vs Astor News

Punch EV vs Comet EV vs Astor Reviews

Punch EV vs Comet EV vs Astor User Ratings

Overall Rating	5/5 2 Ratings 2 Reviews	5/5 3 Ratings 3 Reviews	2.4/5 18 Ratings 16 Reviews
Rating Parameters	4 Exterior	4.7 Exterior	4.4 Exterior
	5 Interior	5 Interior	4.4 Interior
	5 Ride Quality	4.7 Ride Quality	2.5 Ride Quality